This rubric has three levels: Level 1 is the basic academic conversation where students show that they are listening and responding using the Accountable Talk Stems as transitions between participants. Level 2 is a slightly higher level where students paraphrase, cite specific portions of text and elaborate on one another's thinking.
Accountable talk packet for read alouds, FREE. I like this rubric. I'd like to give one to each group and have them place a marker/chip on the score they think they earned as individuals. We could work on having them give each other feedback too.