Which Jelly Belly Flavor Are You? Buttered Popcorn You’re a bit of an oddball. You enjoy being buttered up, but don’t appreciate straight-up lies. You like to keep things popping and always try to stand out in a crowd. People think your attitude is a bit salty at times, but that’s just because they don’t understand your sense of humor. You’re really a sweetheart, with buttery tendencies.