I have not read Twilight, so I can't make a judgement, but this was a pretty interesting story, despite the lack of character development for Padme and Anakin sort of being a jerk, his development was interesting
that doesn't matter! he killed hundreds of innocents and jedi! Jedi are a little bit hypocritical; they say they want to keep the force balanced but just want to destroy the sith. That doesn't sound like balance to me.